Wednesday, June 15, 2011

The Wild Duck - Journal #4

Comments:

Isabel H.: I would agree with saying that the character traits are important to Oedipus, though disagree and say the the plot is essential. The plot of Oedipus gives an overall feeling of the story with a clear beginning, middle, and ending. When performed, it can be expected that everyone already understands the story, and therefore the meaning. The way the characters are presented just add to the performance.

Isabella L.: The formality issue dealing with Hjalmar and Gina is quite insightful and something I hadn't thought of. I can see how that affects the reputation of the family, as well as the closeness between Hedvig and her father. The symbolism you mentioned earlier is interesting. I am wondering why a dog would be the cause of pain and suffering, though. Anyway, your unique ideas are awesome as usual!

Maddie B.: Wow, what an interesting comparison! I like how you were able to contrast a play from the past and a book that focuses on the future. Both of them have conflicting ideas, but still relate to the human experience. The difference in views also shows how different people can be because I am sure Sophocles did not represent the same views as everyone else. Contrasting the two completely different themes really shows how different people are.

No comments:

Post a Comment